Why Michigan public health departments publicize some coronavirus exposure sites but not others – MLive.com

When Oceana County ended up being a hot spot for coronavirus in June, public health officials indicated the huge factor: Outbreaks at five location farm and manufacturing facilities.
Health officials declined to name business, a position that got push back at a June 29 online city center. Residents kept in mind the Grand Traverse Health Department had just publicized the names of eight vineyards and bars visited by a group whose members later on tested positive for COVID-19.

Popular Traverse City wineries, restaurants on possible COVID-19 exposure list

That June 29 discussion in Oceana County is one taking place around the state, a public health departments weigh issues about coronavirus exposure vs. the potential damage to businesses recognized as possible direct exposure websites.

” If I were a COVID-positive individual and I went grocery shopping, unless I stopped to have a great deal of in person discussion with someone, its ruled out a high-risk circumstance” in terms of exposing others to the virus, Morse stated.

” Its very possible that the specific right before you at the filling station was asymptomatic, and no one understands it,” Taylor said. “So its crucial that we all follow that guidelines of masking and washing our hands, all those needed steps to avoid getting it.”

Theres no point of informing individuals about low-risk exposures due to the fact that people must always assume those kind of direct exposure are possible, stated Jeannine Taylor, public information officer for District Health Department

Since the group couldnt identify all individuals they were socializing with during the three-day journey, the Grand Traverse Health Department put out a news release to notify the public and assist find individuals who were potentially exposed, Morse described.

Vail made nationwide headings when she publicized a break out at Harpers Bar in East Lansing, one that was eventually connected to more than 180 cases of coronavirus, making it one of the most significant superspreader occasions in the country.

By contrast, the Oceana County outbreaks involved private businesses not open to the general public, and authorities were able to determine those with high-risk direct exposure, defined as in person interaction with a COVID-positive individual for at least 10 minutes and within six feet without masking.

” My coworkers were simply bouncing that around today,” of when a public announcement is appropriate, said Linda Vail, public health officer for the Ingham County Health Department.

The Traverse City exposures was a “a special situation,” reacted Dr. Jennifer Morse, medical director for District Health Department # 10, which covers Oceana and 9 other counties in northern Michigan. “There was a big party of people; they spent a great deal of time in various bars” and had actually prolonged contact with a number of complete strangers in those facilities.

Coronavirus outbreak of more than 180 cases stemming from Harpers bar was a impolite awakening, owner states

Vail likewise publicized an outbreak at a Lansing veterinary clinic. “There were numerous days of exposure, so that got a public announcement,” she stated.

She put out a news release about a July 4 celebration at Torch Lake that drew hundreds since “those who checked positive couldnt recognize all those they had close contact with.”

” If we can do suitable contact tracing and reach the people we need to reach, theres no need for a public announcement,” she said.

The top concern is to determine individuals whose direct exposure puts them at greater threat of contracting the infection, agreed Lisa Peacock, public health officer for the Benzie-Leelanau District Health Department and the Health Department of Northwest Michigan, that includes Otsego, Emmet, Charlevoix and Antrim counties.

Thats especially true because often by the time the coronavirus case has been confirmed, the danger to others has actually passed– those infected have been separated and business has gone through a deep cleaning, so theres no need for public issue moving forward.

” So theres actually no other option because scenario but to put out a public statement,” Peacock stated.

For the most part, Vail stated, shes resisting calls to put out a list of locations linked to coronavirus cases.

” Were not going to get in scarlet letter mode” of putting out names of services linked to coronavirus when there is no need to do so, Vail stated.

Numerous people at massive Torch Lake July 4 party have evaluated favorable for coronavirus

London said in an email. Individuals need to presume that if they are going out into public and gathering around other people, they stand an excellent possibility of being exposed.”

” We got to the point of community transmission quickly,” which implied people who evaluated positive for coronavirus had been in public places such as restaurants and stores, Conrad stated.

Adam London, health officer for the Kent County Health Department, states his agency does not have a policy, but– like other counties– “well share information if we believe there is public health value in doing so.”

” We desire to shape the narrative that the risk is everywhere in our community,” she said. “Any time you leave your home and interact with other humans, you have a danger of getting this virus. It does not matter whether you prevent Meijer or Wendys or wherever the newest case was determined.

Gillian Conrad, spokeswoman for the Berrien County Health Department, said her company has a comparable policy– theyll openly name organisations only if they cant recognize those at high risk of exposure.

In those cases, “were delighted to support them,” Peacock. “But we dont wish to do any unnecessary damage to their business when its not essential for public health reasons.”

To publicly list those services “would not only be stigmatizing for that specific facility and really detrimental to their continuous company operations, it also gives people an incorrect complacency,” Conrad said.

” To call out a particular location, that just doesnt make good sense,” particularly when any business could have clients or staff members who are asymptomatic providers and never determined, Conrad stated. “It does not adequately portray the risk in both directions– where there is increased threat and where there may be less risk.”

Sometimes, she stated, services are putting out public announcements about a break out to explain why theyre briefly shutting down and the actions theyre taking to deal with the situation.


In addition to cleaning hands frequently and not touching your face, officials suggest practicing social distancing, assuming anyone might be bring the infection.

Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer has actually likewise provided an executive order requiring individuals to use face coverings over their mouth and nose while within confined, public spaces.

Health authorities state you must be remaining at least 6 feet away from others and working from house, if possible.

Usage decontaminating wipes or decontaminating spray cleaners on frequently-touched surfaces in your house (door manages, faucets, counter tops) and bring hand sanitizer with you when you enter into locations like shops.

More on MLive:

Why youre seeing different numbers for Michigans everyday coronavirus cases, and other tips for mining information

Mask mandate dispute echoes safety belt fights of the 1980s

Coronavirus contact tracing faces increasing challenges as some Michigan residents hesitant to take part

Michigans retail alcohol sales an intense area in the middle of coronavirus economy slump

As Michigan braces for another coronavirus rise, here are 6 concerns among public health officials

” We want to form the story that the threat is everywhere in our community,” she stated. It doesnt matter whether you prevent Meijer or Wendys or any place the latest case was recognized.

London said in an email. “In our present scenario, the level of community-wide transmission significantly waters down the value of recognizing possible direct exposure websites. Individuals need to assume that if they are going out into public and gathering around other individuals, they stand a great chance of being exposed.”